Skip to main content
  • Home
  • About
  • Faculty Experts
  • For The Media
  • Videos
  • Topics
    • Alumni
    • Events
    • Faculty
    • Library
    • Research
    • Students
    • All Topics
  • Contact
  • Submit
Media Tip Sheets
  • All News
  • Arts & Culture
  • Business & Economy
  • Campus & Community
  • Health & Society
  • Media, Law & Policy
  • STEM
  • Veterans
  • |
  • Alumni
  • The Peel
  • Athletics
Sections
  • All News
  • Arts & Culture
  • Business & Economy
  • Campus & Community
  • Health & Society
  • Media, Law & Policy
  • STEM
  • Veterans
  • |
  • Alumni
  • The Peel
  • Athletics
  • Home
  • About
  • Faculty Experts
  • For The Media
  • Videos
  • Topics
    • Alumni
    • Events
    • Faculty
    • Library
    • Research
    • Students
    • All Topics
  • Contact
  • Submit
Media Tip Sheets

Leaks at the Supreme Court, what really matters? The leak or the decision?

Friday, May 6, 2022, By Ellen Mbuqe
Share
graduate researchMaxwell School of Citizenship and Public AffairsRoe v. WadeSupreme Court

This week, Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts ordered an investigation on how a draft decision of Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization was leaked to Politico. This leak shows that five justices are preparing a judgment that would strike down Roe v. Wade, which first established the constitutional right to abortion.

Justice Roberts said the leak was “a singular and egregious breach,” and a “betrayal of the confidences of the Court.”

“To the extent this betrayal of the confidences of the Court was intended to undermine the integrity of our operations, it will not succeed,” Chief Justice Roberts said in a statement. “The work of the Court will not be affected in any way.”

But two researchers say that these sorts of leaks from the Supreme Court aren’t the issue.  It is the content of the decisions.

Nathan Carrington, a PhD candidate in political science at Syracuse University’s Maxwell School, and Logan Strother, an Assistant Professor of Political Science at Purdue University, wrote the paper (currently under peer review) “Plugging the Pipe? Evaluating the (Null) Effects of Leaks on Supreme Court Legitimacy.”

“The thread through our research is that it is the outcome of the case, not the leaked material, that will influence how the public views the court,” said Carrington. “If the leak harms the institution, it is because it overturns a popular decision not because it was leaked in advance.”

The paper, “Plugging the Pipe” directly addresses the Dobbs leak as well as other historical leaks such as Dred Scott deliberations and questionable extrajudicial activities taken by the justices, like Justice Fortas’s support for the Vietnam War.

From the paper:

“The data we present here offer no evidence that legitimacy (measured as diffuse support, support for court curbing, and felt obligation) is harmed by leaks, even if those leaks reveal information that the public views as unbecoming of Supreme Court justices. Contrary to some expectations in existing theories, we also find that the Court’s legitimacy is not enhanced by leaks. Instead, it seems that legitimacy afforded to the Court is unaffected.”

“Our research suggests that what matters is not whether the information is obtained via leaks or official channels but instead the substance of that information. In other words, it is the content that people respond to, not the manner by which the information made it to press. These findings have clear implications for the current public controversy surrounding the leak of the draft opinion in Dobbs: the public will react to that decision-based in large part on policy agreement with the Court’s decision to overturn Roe. Any impact the Politico story has on the Supreme Court’s legitimacy is not because of the leak per se but because of the content contained within the leak.”

To schedule an interview with the researchers, please contact Ellen James Mbuqe, executive director of media relations at Syracuse University, at ejmbuqe@syr.edu, or 412-496-0551.

  • Author

Ellen Mbuqe

  • Recent
  • Graduate Students Bring Physics to Local Classrooms With Outreach Program
    Friday, May 27, 2022, By Dan Bernardi
  • COVID-19 Update: Effective Wednesday, June 1, Masking Level Returns to Yellow
    Friday, May 27, 2022, By News Staff
  • Preparing Students for a Life of Success
    Friday, May 27, 2022, By Caroline K. Reff
  • Alumni Draw on Their Military Experience in Their Roles as Teachers
    Thursday, May 26, 2022, By Martin Walls
  • Bringing ‘CSI’ Into the Classroom
    Thursday, May 26, 2022, By Dan Bernardi

More In Media Tip Sheets

Vice Admiral responds to Biden’s trip to Asia

If you are looking for an expert in military and intelligence issues, please see comments from retired Vice Admiral Robert Murrett regarding President Biden’s trip to Asia and the mention of the “United States would intervene militarily if China attempts to…

Media Tip Sheet: Consequences of China Lockdown

As the intense lockdowns continue in China, one of our Syracuse University professors weighed in on possible consequences they may have on the economy. Dimitar Gueorguiev is an associate professor of political science at the Maxwell School of Citizenship and…

Architecture Expert and Researcher of Abortion Clinics On the Future of Access

Last week, a draft decision for Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization was leaked from the Supreme Court and shows that five justices are preparing a judgment that would strike down Roe v. Wade. For reporters covering this ongoing story,…

“Inclusion Should Not Be an Afterthought”: Education and Legal Experts Weigh In on Plan to Update Federal Regulations

For the first time in 45 years, the U.S. Education Department is planning to update federal mandates for how schools and colleges must accommodate students with disabilities. The department is soliciting public comments about how current regulations can be improved…

Response to Putin’s Speech

As we heard earlier today, Russian President Vladimir Putin said he had no choice but to invade Ukraine in his Victory Day speech (CNN). Syracuse University’s Mark Jacobson has responded to this speech (see below). Jacobson is the assistant dean of Washington programs…

Subscribe to SU Today

If you need help with your subscription, contact sunews@syr.edu.

Connect With Us

  • Facebook
  • @SyracuseUNews
  • Youtube
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn
  • @SyracuseU
  • @SyracuseUNews
  • @SUCampus
  • Social Media Directory
  • Accessibility
  • Privacy
  • Campus Status
  • Syracuse.edu
© 2022 Syracuse University News. All Rights Reserved.