Roy Gutterman, Syracuse University Associate Professor and Director of The Tully Center for Free Speech, comments about the recent Supreme Court decision on Lee v. Tam and Packingham v. North Carolina.
Lee v. Tam
“Matal v. Tam, formerly Lee v. Tam, decided today (Monday, June 19) by the Supreme Court, makes sense in a lot of ways. Registering a trademark does not mean that word or group of words is government speech, which would have allowed the government to regulate a message or empower the government to censor an offensive message. The opinion today reiterates a bold First Amendment principle that our laws protect even speech we find offensive or hateful,” says Gutterman.
This case involved a band, The Slants, which sought to register its name for a trademark as an effort to reclaim the epithet from its derogatory and hateful origins. When the Patent and Trademark Office denied the application citing an anti-disparagement provision in the trademark law, the band leader litigated, arguing that the government was suppressing his First Amendment rights to express himself.
“This opinion delves into some interesting doctrine on the history, purpose and application of trademark law as well as how trademark law relates to speech in general,” says Gutterman. “By rejecting the trademark law’s disparagement clause, the court is making a statement that the Patent and Trademark Office and our trademark laws in general should not pass judgment on content, even offensive slogans.”
Packingham v. North Carolina
“In Packingham v. North Carolina, the Supreme Court recognized the growing role of the internet, particularly social media, as a place where First Amendment protections need to be guarded. This case involved a state law barring registered sex offenders from accessing social media. A law like this could render a certain group of citizens totally removed from modern communications. Speech and access to others’ speech are fundamental rights under the First Amendment, and the court properly extends this to social media,” says Gutterman.
There’s a new father-son sportscasting team on the national scene, one with a decidedly Orange background: Ian ’90 and Noah Eagle ’19. Ian finished his second year as the lead announcer for the NCAA men’s basketball tournament and has crafted…
Newhouse School and University Professor Bob Thompson was recently featured on “NBC Nightly News” for his long-running lecture series that uses classic television to bridge generational divides and spark important conversation. The segment, produced by NBC’s Brian Cheung ’15—a University…
For the first time ever, Newhouse creative advertising students entered the Sports Clios and Entertainment Clios competitions and won big. Clios are regarded as some of the hardest awards for creative advertising students to win. At the New York City…
Maxwell School alumna Denise Kalette ’68 got her first byline at age 12, under a poem titled “The Poor Taxpayer” that she submitted to her local newspaper. In a few paragraphs of playful prose, she drew attention to an issue…
Fourteen student-athletes will experience Washington, D.C., next week as part of a new Maymester program hosted by the Syracuse University Institute for Democracy, Journalism and Citizenship (IDJC). The one-week program, Democracy Playbook: DC Media and Civics Immersion for Student-Athletes, will…
If you need help with your subscription, contact sunews@syr.edu.
