Skip to main content
  • Home
  • About
  • Faculty Experts
  • For The Media
  • ’Cuse Conversations Podcast
  • Topics
    • Alumni
    • Events
    • Faculty
    • Students
    • All Topics
  • Contact
  • Submit
Media, Law & Policy
  • All News
  • Arts & Culture
  • Business & Economy
  • Campus & Community
  • Health & Society
  • Media, Law & Policy
  • STEM
  • Veterans
  • University Statements
  • Syracuse University Impact
  • |
  • The Peel
  • Athletics
Sections
  • All News
  • Arts & Culture
  • Business & Economy
  • Campus & Community
  • Health & Society
  • Media, Law & Policy
  • STEM
  • Veterans
  • University Statements
  • Syracuse University Impact
  • |
  • The Peel
  • Athletics
  • Home
  • About
  • Faculty Experts
  • For The Media
  • ’Cuse Conversations Podcast
  • Topics
    • Alumni
    • Events
    • Faculty
    • Students
    • All Topics
  • Contact
  • Submit
Media, Law & Policy

Q&A with Professor Roy Gutterman: Balancing Privacy and National Security

Monday, June 17, 2013, By Kathleen Haley
Share
Newhouse School of Public Communications

guttermanRecent revelations about the U.S. government’s surveillance programs in counterterrorism have jarred the American public into a debate about privacy rights versus national security.

A former National Security Agency contractor employee, Edward Snowden, leaked information that the N.S.A. collects the phone records—including the numbers of both parties, call duration and location data—of millions of Verizon customers. Another N.S.A. program gathers emails, Internet search data and online chats of targeted people outside the United States from such major companies as Google and Facebook.

An expert in communications law, Roy Gutterman, an associate professor of communications law and newspaper and online journalism and director of the Tully Center for Free Speech at the S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications, discusses some implications, similar cases and why we might want to pay attention.

Q: Should the average citizen be concerned about these N.S.A. surveillance programs?

A: It’s still sort of hard to tell whether regular people need to be overly concerned that the government is going to be tapping into their emails or their cell phone conversations. Of course the technology exists that the government can, but it’s really hard to tell at this point.

It sounds mostly like what they’ve been doing is searching metadata—or large caches of data. The government said they are not going after the content, just looking at the broad information.

From a civil liberties standpoint, it’s certainly disturbing to hear that the government might be engaged in all sorts of domestic surveillance. There’s always been sort of a hands-off approach to citizens by the government until and unless there’s probable cause that a law has been broken, in which case the government would get a warrant and judicial approval to conduct surveillance.

Q: Some people believe Edward Snowden is a hero; some think he’s a traitor. Why is he/this situation so polarizing?

A: The public is always skeptical about motive when somebody comes forward. People question whether there’s a financial interest or a broader personal interest, or is this just a way to become a celebrity.

There’s also a segment of the population that views this as anti-American and possibly jeopardizing national security. I’ll acknowledge that is a concern. We have to balance that in the discussion and that this is important information the public does need to know about.

Q: Are there comparisons here to others who have been involved in revealing government secrets, such as Daniel Ellsberg [who leaked the Pentagon Papers in 1971] and Bradley Manning [a U.S. Army soldier accused in 2010 of leaking classified materials]?

A: There’s a definite comparison to Manning, with the type of data, the way it was done and even down to their bios. Both are young, tech-savvy guys who seem to have some sort of dissatisfaction not only with their jobs but with their place in society. They’ve decided to take substantial risks to reveal information that they probably shouldn’t reveal.

The data that Dan Ellsberg revealed was more of a historical context rather than contemporaneous data, and there’s also 40 years of technological differences too. What would Daniel Ellsberg do today if he had access to massive amounts of computerized digital data? This recent case is a little different than taking briefcases of documents to a photocopier in the middle of the night for weeks on end.

Q: What should people be paying attention to as this story plays out in the coming weeks and months?

A: The public needs to be aware of what the government is doing. We’ve always had a concern that the government might be doing things they shouldn’t, going back to J. Edgar Hoover and his FBI G-men. There has been surveillance and there probably always will be. It is just a matter of how intrusive the surveillance is and how many innocent people are affected.

This is also a prime example of some of the problems with the outsourcing of our national security. Maybe the government needs to first start looking at how it protects things, such as secrets or data, before it starts punishing people who break secrecy laws.

Q: What have you found particularly fascinating in regard to freedom of speech and privacy issues?

A: The level of what’s all going on behind closed doors that the public doesn’t know about is extremely fascinating.

And these cases force us to re-evaluate what we consider private. When you’re on Facebook, Gmail or browsing the web, people are watching you—whether it’s the government, advertisers or hackers. We’ve sacrificed a lot of our privacy for the facility to be part of the cool kids’ club on Facebook.

We all operate on a level of trust when we go online—that the site where you do your shopping isn’t going to be corrupted, your data is not going to be hacked and your identity is going to be protected. We all take this stuff for granted until there’s a breach. And it’s not that difficult to have a breach.

 

  • Author

Kathleen Haley

  • Recent
  • Arts and Sciences Hosts Inaugural Scholarship and Research Gala
    Friday, May 9, 2025, By Sean Grogan
  • Chancellor Kent Syverud Honored as Distinguished Citizen of the Year at 57th Annual ScoutPower Event
    Thursday, May 8, 2025, By News Staff
  • New Maymester Program Allows Student-Athletes to Develop ‘Democracy Playbook’
    Thursday, May 8, 2025, By Wendy S. Loughlin
  • From Policy to Practice: How AI is Shaping the Future of Education
    Thursday, May 8, 2025, By Christopher Munoz
  • Kohn, Wiklund, Wilmoth Named Distinguished Professors
    Thursday, May 8, 2025, By Wendy S. Loughlin

More In Media, Law & Policy

New Maymester Program Allows Student-Athletes to Develop ‘Democracy Playbook’

Fourteen student-athletes will experience Washington, D.C., next week as part of a new Maymester program hosted by the Syracuse University Institute for Democracy, Journalism and Citizenship (IDJC). The one-week program, Democracy Playbook: DC Media and Civics Immersion for Student-Athletes, will…

Advance Local, Newhouse School Launch Investigative Reporting Fellowship Program

A new collaboration with Advance Local will provide Newhouse School journalism students opportunities to write and report on investigative projects with local impact for newsrooms across the country. The David Newhouse Investigative Reporting Fellowship program, which launched this year in…

Lauren Woodard Honored for Forthcoming Book on Migration Along Russia-China Border

Lauren Woodard, assistant professor of anthropology, has received the Spring 2025 Association for Slavic, East European and Eurasian Studies (ASEEES) First Book Subvention for her upcoming book on Russia’s migration policies on the Russia-China border. Woodard’s book is titled “Ambiguous…

Maxwell School Proudly Ranks No. 1 for Public Affairs in 2025

The Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs has earned the No. 1 overall spot in the latest U.S. News & World Report Best Public Affairs Schools rankings. This year’s top ranking follows Maxwell’s yearlong celebration of its founding 100…

Cultivation of Talent and Moral Compass Guide University Trustee Richard Alexander L’82

Over the last decade, Richard Alexander L’82 has navigated his chosen profession (the law) and his chosen passion (Syracuse University and its law school) through incredibly challenging waters. As partner, managing partner and chair of one of the nation’s most…

Subscribe to SU Today

If you need help with your subscription, contact sunews@syr.edu.

Connect With Us

  • X
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn
Social Media Directory

For the Media

Find an Expert Follow @SyracuseUNews
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn
  • @SyracuseU
  • @SyracuseUNews
  • Social Media Directory
  • Accessibility
  • Privacy
  • Campus Status
  • Syracuse.edu
© 2025 Syracuse University News. All Rights Reserved.